Competing In the Same Space?
Ben Lupton ... owner of Lightality
Claim: "Bringing a Rich Experience to Blogging"
Goal: To try and make skinning just as easy and feature packed as creating a post. This will be achieved by attempting to design a "CMS for skinning" by including a "Lightality" tag inside the blog properties. (I think he means 'tab' ... but who's quibbling with the master?) The tab will include the following sections: About, General, Settings and Look-and-Feel - which, in turn, will include: Color Themes, Layouts, Posts & panels.
When: Christmas Eve ... because "I'm heading for a month-long holiday to Europe" (Watch out there Yabba ;) )
Claims to have the Lightality Skin released on Oct. 24th, 2005, but waiting for Christmas release so can work on 'problems' and CMS. A preview of the CMS can be found here.
1) (4/3/2 Columns) - only seen pics of 3 and his site is 2.
2) (Show/Hide, Add/Remove, Drag/Re-Order Panels) - 1 & 3 yes, 2 yields scads of dotted boxes.
3) (Blog, Category and Author Avatars) - Seen 1 & 3 ... not 2
4) (Customizable BGs/Layouts/PostSkins/Styles/Themes) - unknown
Some untold stats:
• He claims on the Oct 24th that his site works in IE 6, but not for me.
Okay ... here is a test of the STK pop-up system. This is only a test. For the next 60 seconds ... or however long it takes for you to read the contents of this box ... or however long you keep your mouse hovered over the box (and don't read a thing) ... this box will remain open, revealing detail not included in the original document.
The content is set to "pop", when you hover yer mouse over the little icon. There are currently 4 icons, each with a differently styled background and such:
I also wanted to find one for "extra geeky detail", but haven't settled on a graphic yet. Where are the smilie faces?
Okay ... stk out!
• He has a trackback icon, but no trackback address (or permalink address for that matter) shows on individual posts. When you click the trackback link ... it indicates you need to log in to leave a message.
• The email icon, when clicked ... opens up an email client (security breach?) dunno ... no "To:" addy is filled out ;)
• Commentors won't be happy tho. Although you must be a registered user to MAKE A comment, any idiot can right click and view source to get the email address of every commentor. :p
• Ergometrics suck. Can't determine number of comments (total doesn't show till you actually VIEW comments). Can't link any articles via a permalink b/c none is displayed (and prolly wouldn't work anyway b/c of the weird js interface). New time visitors will have fun figuring out how to READ the flippin article to begin with ... and of course, as previously explained ... those with IE6, despite his claims, won't get to even if they DO figure out the one, b/c of javascript errors.
Speaking of errors ... and i'm only hashing this again because I want to document the numbers: (XHTML) - FAILS on 'transitional' and what's worse ... no character encoding is defined ... 182 XHTML errors. (CSS) - Irrelevant, b/c XHTML is so badly screwed up.
Two more things: (1) TABLES layout? Gimme a break (2) Got JS turned off? Site is little more than a JPG image. :o
OKAY ... This guy scares me. Not just b/c of what he's like on the boards, but b/c i think his idea is really GREAT ... just his execution sucks (and of course, he has no real clue). What do you think of an idea like he's describing, where one can basically build an object-oriented skin from a back office tab? The big problem that i see with it: to allow the kind of flexibility that would suit 80% of people's personal wants/desires/needs ... the interface would be too cumbersome for the average joe. But still ... esp if color and images could be customized ... it would seem you could hit 50% of ppls needs and still have a lightweight, user-friendly interface.
OKAY ... enough on this. I gotta de-blubbertise myself for a while ... i feel yucky all over
Recent Comments